by Jim » Thu Feb 09, 2006 9:40 pm
Mike, there is a small problem with asking me about cockpit sizes!
Firstly I haven't paddled a Jubilee yet (do I dare borrow Pelagics? I may need a boat leash), secondly almost all the sea kayaks I have previously paddled, certainly all those I've spent any real time in have had ocean cockpits, and thirdly I paddle river boats that people half my size complain feel tight......
The keyhole sized opening was certainly large enough for getting in and out without any trouble. I was able to get my knees under the deck without undue strain, although it is worth noting that Douglas had already removed the seat padding from the Nordkapp because it was too tight on his thighs with it.
I have to say that for space in the boat, i.e. under the deck, the ocean cockpit actually gives you more, but for ease of getting in and out, the keyhole clearly excels. The issue is that with an ocean cockpit the deck continues to rise towards you and curve up in the middle for you to slide your knees in, and you have choices about paddling knees up in the middle, or out to the side - all with grip under the deck. A Keyhole cockpit cuts off the last few inches of the foredeck rise, and the flat elevation of the spraydeck means you don't have that accomodating curve for your knees, plus the thighbraces take out a little vertical space. Also if you paddle knees up in the middle, you first have to extricate them from under the thigh braces, and then you have nothing solid to brace them against. I actually think that, assuming one is mobile enough for the more balancy, more slide in from the rear method of entry (I am sure it wouldn't suit Douglas and suspect it wouldn't suit Mike), that an ocean cockpit actually gives you more room in the boat.
I have to say that jumping in and out ofthe boat with the keyhole cockpit was very much more easily acheived than it is with my ocean cockpit. I can see why river paddlers like this (we are in and out so much inspecting and portaging) and I understand why some sea paddlers like it, but I have to say that when an average day in a sea boat lasts 4-8 hours and I only have to get in and out twice in all that time (once for lunch, once for arriving), then for me personally, the ocean cockpit wins!
Clark, you may have been way out in geological timescale, but you did get the right coast first time!
JIM